Controversial compaq-hp merger: lessons learned

The merger between Compaq and Hewlett Packard (HP) in 2002 was a highly debated and controversial decision made by then-CEO Carly Fiorina. The merger was seen as a way to revitalize HP and overcome the challenges it was facing in the rapidly changing IT industry. However, the merger ultimately failed to deliver the promised benefits and led to Fiorina's departure from the company.

Content Index


At the time of the merger, HP was struggling to keep up with competitors like IBM and Dell. The company's reputation was strong, but it was seen as out of touch with the industry. Fiorina believed that a merger with Compaq, a leading provider of PCs and IT services, would help HP regain its competitive edge.

The merger faced significant opposition, particularly from Walter Hewlett, son of HP's co-founder, who strongly opposed the deal. Despite the resistance, Fiorina pushed through the merger, promising shareholders significant synergies and improved performance.

The Merger's Failure

Unfortunately, the merger between Compaq and HP failed to deliver the expected results. Instead of gaining value, HP experienced a decline in performance and lost considerable market share. Critics of the merger compared it to tying two stones together and expecting them to float.

One of the main reasons for the merger's failure was the challenging business environment for PC manufacturers. Companies like Dell were pushing down margins, making it difficult for HP to compete effectively. The merger with Compaq only added to HP's problems instead of solving them.

Budget-friendly and reliable: hewlett packard refurbished computersBudget-friendly and reliable: hewlett packard refurbished computers

Fiorina's Departure

Carly Fiorina stepped down as CEO of HP in 2005, citing differences with the board over the execution of the company's strategy. While her leadership style and communication skills were praised, Fiorina failed to execute the merger's strategy effectively. HP's performance lagged behind its primary rivals, IBM and Dell, and the board believed a change in leadership was necessary.

The board's decision to replace Fiorina was seen as a necessary step to prevent further decline and revive the company's fortunes. Robert Wayman, HP's CFO, took over as interim CEO, and Patricia Dunn was appointed non-executive chairman.

Future Strategy for HP

Following Fiorina's departure, there were questions about HP's future strategy. Some speculated that the company might consider breaking up into two separate entities, one focused on corporate customers and the other serving individual clients. This move was previously opposed by Fiorina but could be reconsidered under new leadership.

However, the new leadership faced a challenging situation. Selling off the PC business, as IBM did with Lenovo, was a possibility, but finding a buyer willing to pay for those assets was uncertain. HP still possessed valuable assets, but a concrete strategy was needed to steer the company in the right direction.

Lessons Learned

Carly Fiorina's tenure at HP highlighted the importance of effective execution and strategic decision-making. While she was praised for her leadership style and determination, her failure to deliver on the merger's promises ultimately led to her departure.

Hpq stock dividend: how often does hewlett packard pay dividends?

compaq hewlett packard merger - Why did Compaq go out of business

HP's experience with the Compaq merger serves as a reminder that mergers and acquisitions are not always the solution to a company's problems. A clear strategy, proper execution, and consideration of market dynamics are crucial for success.

compaq hewlett packard merger - Why did HP and Compaq merger fail

The merger between Compaq and Hewlett Packard was a controversial decision that failed to deliver the promised benefits. Carly Fiorina's departure from HP highlighted the importance of effective execution and strategic decision-making. Moving forward, HP would need to reassess its strategy and find a way to regain its competitive edge in the rapidly changing IT industry.

Hp small printers: portable printing solutions

Go up

We use our own and third-party cookies to prepare statistical information and show you personalized content and services through navigation analysis. Accept them or set your preferences. More Information